What I Check in Search Console Before I Touch Anything
Clients want to start with changes. I start with Search Console, and I do not touch a page until I have read what Google has already said about the site. Google talks constantly; Search Console is where it talks. Most of what owners pay me to discover is sitting in there, unopened, some of it for years. I wrote the long version of the indexing side of this at christopherabraham.com; this is the working checklist, in the order I actually run it and for the reasons I run it in that order.
First: is anything officially wrong?
Manual actions and security issues, before everything. A manual action is Google telling you, in writing, exactly what it objects to; owners routinely pay for months of "SEO" while one sits unread. If either screen has an entry, that entry is the engagement until it is cleared, because no other work outruns a penalty or a hacked-site flag. This check takes ninety seconds and I have seen it end engagements on the spot: the mystery traffic collapse, explained by a notice nobody had opened since the previous developer left.
Second: what is Google actually indexing?
The Pages report, read by reason, not by total. "Crawled, currently not indexed" in bulk means Google looked and declined, which is a quality and duplication question. "Discovered, currently not indexed" means it has not bothered, which is a crawl-budget and internal-linking question. "Alternate page with proper canonical" in bulk means your templates are arguing with each other. Each reason is a different repair, and treating them as one problem called "indexing" is how money gets wasted. The totals at the top of the report are the least useful numbers in it; a site can have a healthy total and a fatal distribution, with the money pages sitting in the declined pile while the tag archives index beautifully.
Third: which queries almost work?
The Performance report, filtered for queries sitting at positions 8 to 20 with real impressions. Those pages are already understood by Google and already nearly chosen. Improving them is the cheapest visibility a site owns, and it is invisible until you sort the data this way. I read this before any content planning, because the plan writes itself from it: these are the questions the market is already asking this site, at the exact distance where better titles, better answers, and better internal links actually move the number. Chasing new keywords while positions 8 to 20 sit unworked is buying a second boat before patching the first.
Fourth: what changed, and when?
Every traffic mystery has a date. I line the drop date up against the site's history: migrations, redesigns, plugin changes, the day someone "cleaned up" the old URLs. Nine times out of ten the cause is in the calendar, not the algorithm, and the repair is undoing or completing a specific past change. The classic version: a redesign ships in March, the old service pages are deleted because the new ones "cover that," no redirects are written because nobody listed the old URLs, and by June the owner is shopping for an SEO to fix what Google supposedly did to him. Google did nothing to him. The evidence is sitting in the Pages report, dated.
Fifth: do the plumbing signals agree?
Sitemaps, robots.txt, and canonicals, checked as one system. Is the sitemap current, does it list only URLs that return 200 and carry no noindex, does robots.txt block anything the sitemap submits, do the canonicals point where the owner thinks they point? Individually these are trivia. Together they are the instructions the site gives Google about itself, and on a surprising share of sites they contradict each other in at least one place. A crawler reads instructions literally. Contradictory instructions are not a gray area; they are a bug.
What do I write down?
Everything above becomes the deliverable: the cause, the evidence for the cause, and the repair, in the order the repairs should be done. Not a dashboard export, not a list of warnings with the domain pasted in, but a document an owner can hand to a developer, another firm, or me. That is the whole business model, and it is why the checklist is public: the checklist is not the value. The judgment about what the checklist finds on your site is.
Why sell this as a checklist?
Because this hour is the diagnosis, and the diagnosis is the product. One problem, \$160: the cause, the evidence, the written fix. The whole property, \$750: the same read end to end, sequenced by impact. You can run this checklist yourself now that you have it; owners who would rather have it run for them can start on my SEO services page.
📞 Call/Text: 202-352-5051
📧 Email: [email protected]
📅 Book a Call: 30-minute call with me via Calendly

